According to the popular Mongolian legend, in the nineteenth century, at the time of the Eighth Bogdo Gegeen, Jebtsundamba Rinpoche, who was the head of Mongolian Buddhism, a Mongolian monk whose name remains unknown, predicted that Buddhism in Mongolia will be assaulted by inimical forces. He further prophesized that some time after the destruction of Buddhism in the country, Arhat Bakula will come to Mongolia to revitalize the Mongolian Buddhist tradition. He further foretold that after Buddhism among Mongols receives “a crushing blow at the hands of the red barbarians in the early twentieth century” the Mongolian Buddhist cultural heritage will be restored to its previous glory. The well-known Mongolian scholar and monk, Zava Damdin (rTsa bar rTa mrgrin dka ‘bcu, 1867-1937) makes reference to such a prophecy in his Golden Book (Altan Devter), but points out the Mañjushri Ullatantra as the original source of the prophecy.
Following the aforementioned prediction, in the Banner (khoshuu) of Agi nobleman (üizen gün) of Sain Noyen Khan aimag, a thangka was made for the sake of worshiping Arhat Bakula. The thangka depicts sixteen Arhats of the Buddha, with Bakula Arhat occupying a central position in the painting and holding a mongoose in his hands. He is surrounded by fifteen other Arhats and the Buddha Shakyamuni, who is attended by Shariputra and Maudgalyayana, depicted above the head of Bakula Arhat. On the upper left and right corners of the paintings are depicted two Bodhisattva figures, Tara and Mañjusrī. On the bottom of the painting are the four Maharajas, the guardians of the four cardinal directions, and on the lower, right side, above the fourth Maharaja there is a representation of the seated Hashang. During the years of the communist revolution, in every monastery, during daily ritual services, lamas recited the prayer gNas brtan phag mchod (Salutation and Worship of the Elders), in which Bakula Arhat is mentioned as learned and holy.
On May 19, 1917, on the day commemorating the Buddha’s parinirana son was born at Mangtro palace to Yeshe Wangmo, the princess of Zangla and a niece of Lobsang Yeshe Tenpa Gyaltsen (bLob bzang ye shes brtan pa rgyal mtshan, 1890-1917), the prince of Zangskar, considered to be the Eighteenth incarnation of Bakula Arhat. It is said that prior to his death, the Eighteenth Bakula Lobsang Yeshe Tenpa Gyaltsen foretold his next birth, indicating one of the four daughters of his sister as his future mother. His next incarnation, born as a son of Yeshe Wangmo, was recognized as the Nineteenth Kushok Bakula Lobsang Thubten Chognor (bLob bzang thub bstan bchog nor) and confirmed as such at his age of six by the Thirteenth Dalai Lama. After receiving a preliminary education in Ladakh, at the age of ten he set out to Drepung Monastery in Lhasa, where he stayed for fourteen years and earned the highest monastic degree with honors, the Geshe Lharampa degree. Returning to Ladakh at the time of India’s transition from the centuries-long colonial rule to independence, and witnessing the poor social conditions of the people in his home state, the Nineteenth Kushok Bakula (from now on called Kushok Bakula) applied himself to securing the religious, social, and political welfare of the people of Ladakh. He thus continued the work of his predecessor, the Eighteenth Bakula Lobsang Yeshe Tenpa Gyaltsen, who worked for the welfare of the people of Ladakh and ensured a tax exemption for all Buddhist monasteries in the region. In the 1950s, when the existence of Buddhist monasteries in Ladakh was threatened, the Nineteenth Kushok Bakula established two organizations, the All Ladakh Gonpa Association and the Ladakh Buddhist Association committed to the preservation of the Buddhist monastic life in Ladakh. His concern for the economical wellbeing of the people of Ladakh and for their religion and culture led him to a political career, which lasted fifty years, never separated from his Buddhist practice and religious works. Becoming the first Minister from Ladakh in the Jammu and Kashmir, first to represent Ladakh as member of Lok Sabha in the Indian parliament and the first Ladakhi member of the Minorities Commission of India, he championed the rights of the people of Ladakh, who were experiencing the hardships of poverty, illiteracy, and abuse from corrupt landlords and governmental officials. His efforts yielded several significant results for his home state:
the preservation of the unique identity and Buddhism of Ladakh,
the recognition of Ladakh as a part of India in 1948 and thereby the state’s liberation from the long-lasting neglect of the rulers of Jammu and Kashmir who controlled the state and hindered its economic development, and
the creation of unprecedented educational opportunities for the young people of Ladakh.
Convinced that peace is possible if people genuinely follow the fundamental ethical principles of Buddhism, the Nineteenth Kushok Bakula became committed to nurturing peace and facilitating harmony among different peoples. As the Vice President of the Asian Buddhist Conference for Peace (ABCP), which he co-established with S. Gombojav, the abbot of Gandantegchenling Monastery in Ulaanbaatar in 1969, and later as the President of the ABCP, he helped shape its policies and programs. During the Fifth General Conference of the ABCP, held in Mongolia’s capital, Ulaanbaatar in 1979, the Nineteenth Kushok Bakula expressed his perspective on solving social and political frictions in Asia by stating: “We can overcome all tension if we learn to live in peace, remove all misunderstandings, and get rid of fissiparous tendencies.”
Kushok Bakula persevered in the career of a social activist, a politician, and a diplomat not merely because of the difficult social and political conditions that warranted the amelioration in his native Ladakh, but also because of the oppressive circumstances of various Mongol ethnic groups in the former Soviet Union and in Mongolian People’s Republic. Learning about the prohibition of religious expression and of the demise of Buddhism in the countries ruled by communist governments, he felt compelled to positively affect socio- political changes in these regions. According to his own words, his “karmic connection” with Buddhists in Russia and Mongolia emerged in 1917, in the same year when the Bolshevik Revolution was victorious in Russia; from that time onwards, his desire to visit these countries never waned. While many Tibetan Lamas living in India sought to travel to the United State and Europe, where religious freedom allowed the spread of Buddhist teachings, the Nineteenth Kushok Bakula chose to journey to the northern and northwestern parts of Asia. Speaking of his inner calling, he said: “A spread of Buddhism to the West was a very important achievement of the twentieth century, which may have a far reaching effect. I myself had a few such opportunities (to set out to the West), but I did not go because in reality I never felt a strong interest in that. However, when the opportunity to leave for Russia was presented, I took it.
This may sound strange, but I always passionately endeavored to get there.” Thus, he became the first Buddhist monk to visit the Soviet Union and its regions of Buryatia and Kalmykia, as well as socialist Mongolia, and communist China, where he advocated peace and nuclear disarmament. In 1968, on the invitation of the Soviet Ministry for Religious Affairs, the Nineteenth Kushok Bakula paid his first visit to the Soviet Union as the head of a religious delegation from India to discuss the creation of the Asian Buddhist Conference for Peace. This historic visit also included his travels to Ulan Ude, the capital of Buryatia and to Leningrad (now St. Peterburg). Bato Tsybenovich Tsybenov, who served as the advisor for religious affairs at that time and accompanied him to Ulan Ude, recounted the excitement of the Buddhists of Buryatia stirred by Kushok Bakula’s visit, large crowds of excited people hindered his departure by standing in front of the car that was taking him to the airport. Since that first official journey, Kushok Bakula regularly visited various Mongolian ethnic groups living in Buryatia, Kalmykia, and Mongolia. During one of his diplomatic visits to the Soviet Union, he appealed to Soviet leaders to return to Russian Buddhists their temple in St. Petersburg, which was built by the renowned Buryat Lama Agwan Dorjev (1853-1938) but later vandalized by the Red Army and made into a zoology institute. He saw the new political movements of Perestroika and Glasnost (1985-1991), which strove to bring economic reforms and democratization of the communist party in the Soviet Union, as an opportunity for Russian Buddhists to become socially engaged with the goal of ending the cold war. In his speech given at the banquet celebrating one thousand years of the Russian Orthodox Church in 1999, Kushok Bakula pointed out that Perestroika and Glasnost are not a cause for staying quiet, but for making a new effort in mobilizing the Buddhist community in a struggle for peace and vigorous resolution.
In 1989, Kushok Bakula also became the first Buddhist teacher to visit Kalmykia. Commenting on his experiences during that visit, he expressed his empathy and concern for Kalmyk Mongols in these words:
“I made several trips to Kalmykia, to the region of Volga, to the people, who suffered not only from the communist storm, as everyone everywhere did, but who also endured the great pain and humiliation under the rule of Stalin’s regime. Not only their culture was destroyed, but also all people were forced to leave the homeland and were forcibly resettled far from the Volga region. Thousands died… In Kalmykia I was struck. I saw a complete erosion of their culture without any sign of the preservation of the remainder of the culture. A strange feeling arose in me, to find myself in the midst of the people of the Mongolian origin and to see that they behave more like Russians. But their passionate desire and determination to restore their culture made me happy.”
In 1969, a year after his first visit to Russia, Kushok Bakula made his first visit to Mongolia’s capital Ulaanbaatar. Upon his arrival in Mongolia, he emphasized the urgency for organizing activities related to world peace, with this message:
In all countries of the world, Let all living beings be free from disease and drought.
Eliminate disaster and war so that Peace could prevail, and with peace on the Earth, Let all people enjoy a happy life.
During that visit he discovered that the faith of Mongolian Buddhists had not entirely vanished, despite the seven decades of religious repression and communist ideology imposed by the Mongolian People’s Revolutionary Party. Since religious teachings in public were still prohibited at the time of Kushok Bakula’s first visit to Mongolia, he quietly offered them to a small group of the faithful in his hotel room. This was the first of his regular visits and teachings in Mongolia through which he enabled Mongolian Buddhists to strengthen their weakened ties to Buddhism.
D. Choijamts, the abbot of Gandanthegcheling Monastery in Mongolia, who at the time of Kushok Bakula’s first visit to Mongolia was a student at the monastery, remarked on Kushok Bakula’s benefaction to Mongolian Buddhists during that period: “In spite of the fact that the time was severe and security was rigorous during the socialist regime in Mongolia, we would secretly find opportunities for the faithful to receive teaching and empowerments from our precious teacher, Bakula Rinpoche. These occasions enabled the Mongolian disciples to form a solid and indestructible relationship with our Guru. Then the peaceful transition to democracy in 1990, in the Year of the Horse, gave us the opportunity to enjoy freedom and practice faith and spirituality freely.”
In 1989, just a year before the peaceful democratic revolution in Mongolia, Kushok Bakula was appointed as the Indian Ambassador to Mongolia. Thus, he became the first Buddhist monk to hold an ambassadorial position and take part in the development of the bilateral relations between India and what will soon to become a democratic Mongolia for the next ten years. In this new role, he arrived in Mongolia on December 31, 1989, and on January 2, 1990, he presented his diplomatic credentials to J. Batmunkh, who at that time held the post of the Chairman of the Great People’s Khural (Mongolian Parliament). On that occasion, Kushok Bakula expressed his view of the Buddha Shakyamuni as the first Indian Ambassador to Mongolia and bewildered the Mongolian governmental officials by attending the meeting in his monastic robes and presenting them a ceremonial, white, silken scarf (khata) as an expression of his wishes for their long and prosperous lives. Several months after that, he witnessed the overthrow of one-party rule and the establishment of a new political system that was supportive of the human rights, freedom of religious expression, and democratic, multiparty elections. The democratic changes in the country allowed Kushok Bakula to openly assist Mongolian Buddhists in their attempts to revitalize their Buddhist knowledge and practice and to rebuild their temples and monasteries, most of which were razed to the ground under Stalin’s influence.
Kushok Bakula began to travel across the extensive, rugged terrains and dusty roads of Mongolia. During his frequent expeditions to Mongolia’s rural areas, he visited the rebuilt temples, imparted teachings to Buddhists in rural areas, performed rituals of blessings and empowerments, and called for the return to Buddhist ethical values, which were neglected during the communist period.
As Kushok Bakula’s popularity grew, Mongolian people from various corners of the country were converging on the Indian Embassy, waiting in queues every morning to receive his blessings, and soon he became affectionately called among Mongolians as Elchin Bagsh (Ambassador Teacher). On May 29, 1991, Kushok Bakula initiated the first public celebration of the Buddha’s birthday in democratic Mongolia, which was held at the National Cultural and Recreational Center and attended by thousands of people.
Another significance of that event was that for the first time after the seven decades of religious oppression, Mongolian political leaders, headed by the President of Mongolia, Punsalmaagiin Ochirbat, participated at a public, religious ceremony.
Observing the conditions of Buddhist monasticism, Kushok Bakula noticed the pressing need for the proper training of Mongolian monks, among whom many did not adhere to monastic regulations for a variety of reasons, one being the lack of monastic institutions that could house monks and provide them with daily necessities and adequate education. He often publicly pointed out the importance of upholding one’s monastic vows, which he saw as indispensible for the flourishing of Buddhism in Mongolia. Not long after filling the post of Indian Ambassador, Kushok Bakula procured Indian visas and funding for Mongolian monks who desired to study in Tibetan monasteries in India such as Gomang, Sera, the Buddhist School of Dialectics in Dharamsala, the Central Institute of Tibetan Higher Studies, and so on, at the time when it was virtually impossible for Mongolians to acquire such a visa. More significantly, in 1999, Kushok Bakula built the Pethub Stangey Choskor Ling Monastery in Ulaanbaatar, which is commonly referred to by Mongolians as Bakula Rinpoche’s Monastery. The monastery was built in the Tibetan architectural style, and it is named after Kushok Bakula’s main monastery in Ladakh. This monastery in Ulaanbaatar became a prominent venue for the training of young monks, public teachings, and ritual empowerments bestowed by Kushok Bakula himself. Until recently, in addition to Gandantegchenling Monastery, now recognized as the official center of Mongolian Buddhists, Bakula Rinpoche’s monastery was the only teaching monastery that provides room and board for the young monks. Prior to granting the novice ordination to young candidates, some of whom came from as far as Buryatia, Kushok Bakula carefully examined the candidates and their families to determine their motivation and suitability for a monastic life. At the time when well trained Buddhist teachers were in great need in Mongolia, Kushok Bakula brought highly qualified lamas from Ladakh and Sikkim to educate students in his monastery.
To this day, young monks of his monastery continue to be educated in Buddhist doctrine, in the classical Tibetan and Mongolian languages, English, mathematics, and geography. Upon graduation, the best students are sent to India for higher monastic education.
With the financial assistance from the Tibet Foundation U.K., in 2002, a clinic of traditional Buddhist medicine was built on the monastery’s grounds, where Mongolian and Tibetan traditional doctors offer medical care to both monastic and lay communities.
G. Luvsantseren, the head of the Mongolian Buddhist Studies Institute, who worked closely with Kushok Bakula in the ABCP, in his commemorative speech highlighted the fact that Kushok Bakula appreciated the unique, Mongolian Buddhist culture and that his “unique venture was not aimed at Indianising or Tibetanising the monks” in Mongolia. As a fervent advocate of human rights, Kushok Bakula made sure that the spiritual needs of Mongolian women and their contribution to Buddhism would not be neglected. To that end, he opened the Lay Women Buddhist Organization and gave monastic ordination to women, the first ever in modern Mongolia.
Kushok Bakula’s various activities dedicated to the restoration of the Mongolian Buddhism and culture included his undertaking to convince the Indian government to allow for the relics of the Buddha, kept at the National Museum in New Delhi, to be brought to Mongolia for viewing. As a result of that effort, in August of 1993, the Indian Deputy Minister of Culture brought the Buddha’s relics to Ulaanbaatar. The relics were on display at the Central Cultural Palace for a month and worshipped by tens of thousands of people.
Reflecting on that event, Mr. N. Enkhbayar, who held various political posts throughout his career, such as those of the President of the Mongolian People’s Revolutionary Party, the Minister of Culture to the President of Mongolia (2005-2009), said: “For the Mongolian people who had suffered many years of cultural persecution and were denied practice of their faith, the coming of the holy Buddha relics was like coming of the Lord Buddha to our land.” Since in the early years of Mongolian democracy, literature on Buddhist teachings was virtually non-existent in the modern Mongolian language, so Kushok Bakula encouraged N. Enkhbayar to translate The Teaching of the Buddha from English to Mongolian.
The book was published in 1995 in Japan and distributed to Mongolian Buddhists free of charge. On yet another inspiration of Kushok Bakula, the International Buddhist Institute in Mongolia was established with the aim to enable international students to conduct research on Mongolian Buddhism. He also invited other eminent Buddhist teachers to come to Mongolia, including the H.H. the Fourteenth Dalai, who came to Mongolia for the first time in 1992, where gave public teachings and the Kalchakra initiation. Aware of the early contacts of the Mongols with the Sakya order of the Tibetan Buddhism, which dates to the thirteenth century when Qubilai Khaan brought to his court the Sakya master Phagpa Lama (‘Phags pa) from Tibet, Kushok Bakula made it possible for Mongolians to reestablish their historical connection with the Sakya order. By inviting one of the heads of the Tibetan Sakya order, Sakya Trinzin Rinpoche to Mongolia, who arrived there in the summer of 1995, Kushok Bakula, who belonged to the Gelug order of Tibetan Buddhism, demonstrated to Mongolian Buddhists his nonsectarian approach to Buddhism and his genuine desire for the development of Buddhism in Mongolia.
As the Indian Ambassador, Kushok Bakula sought ways to facilitate India’s fruitful cultural relations with Mongolia that would enrich the lives of Mongolian people and create new educational opportunities for young people. In so doing, he set up the Indian Cultural Center, equipped with audio-visual material, books, artworks, and the like to enable Mongolians to study Indian languages and classical Indian dances. He also helped to establish the Mongolian-Indian Friendship Farm in the city of Darkhan and the Training and Industrial Center in Ulaanbaatar, which was named after Rajiv Gandhi. Likewise, under his initiative, more than fifty Mongolian students were sent for training in Indian colleges and universities under various exchange programs. Ts. Gombosüren, who was a Mongolian Foreign Minister from 1988 to 1996, said this of Kushok Bakula’s ambassadorial service: “There are many major developments that took place in promoting bilateral relations between our two countries (India and Mongolia), and one can clearly see the impact of tremendous contribution made by Kushok Bakula Rinpoche.”
Acknowledging Kushok Bakula’s contribution to the Mongolian political, social, and religious life at the time when democratic governance in Mongolia was in its infancy, the first democratically elected President of Mongolia, P. Ochirbat, who governed Mongolia from 1990-1997, wrote of Kushok Bakula’s constructive inputs in the highest of terms. He pointed out that by the end of 1990, there were about fifty reopened temples and monasteries with 1,000 monks; but due to restrictive regulations in the country, it was difficult to coordinate the functioning of temples and monasteries, which were in disarray and had many obstacles regarding religious activities. There was no universally recognized leader of Mongolian Buddhists either. The new government dissolved the Council of Religious Affairs that was set up earlier and replaced it by a supernumerary Religious Council led by a presidential adviser. It was seen as necessary to formulate and declare the state policy regarding religion and to enact a law that could guarantee religious freedom and preservation of ancient, cultural heritage of Mongolia.
Mr. Ochirbat also stated: “Bakula Rinpoche advised the people to accept change and maintain peace, harmony, and good will in accord with the cherished values of civilized behavior. Bakula Rinpoche’s approach to human psychology brought about desired change, yielding peaceful and meaningful results.” N. Enkhbayar in a similar manner indicated Kushok Bakula’s important role in the peaceful solution to political changes in Mongolia, which found itself at a crossroad when a new political experiment was being made, which involved a complete departure from the past and a change for the better. He said:
“It was due to our Buddhist heritage and Rinpoche’s presence in the country that the transition to democracy in Mongolia, unlike in other socialist countries, was so peaceful. Rinpoche was an integral part of this great transformation and he played an active role in these changes through his advice, assistance, and participation… Young people, including those who actively participated in democratic changes in Mongolia, sought Rinpoche’s guidance and help. Many politicians and businessmen also sought audience with Rinpoche to seek his advice… Bakula Rinpoche’s advice was simple, yet convincing… If not Bakula Rinpoche, who else could have guided the people through these changes? …In all his interactions with Mongolian people, Rinpoche enthused unity among them and asked the people to work for preserving Mongolia’s distinct national identity and independence.
And at the same time, he exhorted them to work for the development of the country… For his yeomen service to the nation, the President of Mongolia (P. Ochirbat) conferred upon him ‘Polar Star,’ a state award, in 2001.”
It seems not everyone appreciated Kushok Bakula’s council at that time of political turbulence, as certain political circles that resisted change in the country accused Kushok Bakula of interfering in the domestic affairs of Mongolia, and some even suggested that he be sent back to India.
On the basis of his endeavors and accomplishments among the Mongols, to this day Kushok Bakula has been revered as a prophesized, bodhisattvic emanation of Arhat Bakula, who fulfilled the hopes and prayers of Mongolian Buddhists. In the year 2008, on the occasion of the ninety-first anniversary of Kushok Bakula’s birthday, several distinguished figures in Mongolian political, cultural, and academic spheres wrote of him in their essays either indirectly or directly as a bodhisattva who brought the nineteenth- century prophecy to reality. Lama G. Purevbat, the most prominent Buddhist artist in Mongolia and the founder and director of the Mongolian Institute of Buddhist Art, referred to Kushok Bakula as “our great teacher Bodhisattva, who made many meritorious deeds to restore and revive Buddhism in Mongolia for the fourth time in the history of our country.” Similarly, G. Luvsantseren, the Director of Mongolian Studies Institute, wrote about Kushok Bakula’s historic role in Mongolia in this way: “Kushok Bakula Rinpoche was a Bodhisattva who dedicated his life for the welfare of all living beings on this earth… [regarded] as a Great Teacher who had come from India to perform this historic task.” The previously mentioned, first democratically elected President of Mongolia, P. Ochirbat, wrote this: “[He] came to Mongolia as a divine messenger at the time of peaceful transformation to democracy and inspired our people.” Ochirbat further stated: “I always looked to him with prayer in my heart to gain inner strength and confidence when our country was passing through a crucial phase of history in the period of democratic reforms… Bakula Rinpoche recognized distinctive characteristics of Mongolian democracy and the historic necessity to develop its national culture and traditions, to restore religion to its pristine glory with emphasis on reviving Buddhism as an inseparable part of Mongolian cultural heritage.”
During his diplomatic service in Mongolia, Kushok Bakula travelled to Beijing every two months on his diplomatic mission. During those visits, at the request of Chinese Buddhists, he discretely offered teachings at the time when giving religious teachings there without governmental permission was prohibited. At the conclusion of his diplomatic service, Kushok Bakula returned to India in the year 2000, but he regularly visited Mongolia, imparting teachings and empowerments, despite his frail health. On November 24, 2004, Kushok Bakula died at the age of eighty-seven. His body was kept in Delhi for several days for viewing by many high political and religious dignitaries of India and other countries. On November 7, a special Indian Air Force plane carried Kushok Bakula’s body, covered with a national flag to Leh, the capital of Ladakh, and it landed in the airport renamed as “Bakula Rinpoche Airport.” Monks in Leh performed prayers and rituals for fourteen days, and on November 16, 2003, Kushok Bakula’s body was cremated with state honors and the police and military men fired shots in the air as an expression of respect. Thousands of monks and laypeople attended the cremation to collect his ashes for blessing. Within a year of the cremation, a gold-gilded, silver stupa measuring 3.5 m was constructed for keeping his relics and placed in his monastery in Ladakh. According to the report of Sonam Wangchuk Shakspo, who worked in various capacities with Kushok Bakula and as Indian Cultural Attaché in Mongolia during Kushok Bakula’s ambassadorial post, shortly after the cremation of Kushok Bakula’s body, a mongoose appeared in the courtyard of Pethub monastery in Ladakh, ran into the private room of Kushok Bakula, and sat on his cushion.
While staying there for forty-nine days, the mongoose behaved like a pet and ate only vegetarian food from the hands of the amused monks. At the completion of the forty-ninth day, it disappeared.
A year after Kushok Bakula’s passing, on November 24, 2005, a boy by name Thupstan Ngawang was born in Ladakh, who was to be recognized as Arhat Bakula’s twentieth incarnation and confirmed as such on February 26, 2008 by the Fourteenth Dalai Lama. As this news reached Mongolia, requests for the young Bakula’s visit to Mongolia were made, indicating that a connection between Arhat Bakula and the Mongols that was established by the Nineteenth Kushok Bakula will continue. What form that connection will take remains to be seen.
The life and work of the Nineteenth Kushok Bakula exemplify both—
the responsibility that a person who is accepted into the lineage of incarnations of the renowned Buddhist practitioners takes on in order to follow the example of his predecessors, and
the unique features of his way in the world that arise in response to social realities of his time.
Ladakh Review,
Vol 4
The Life and Work of the Nineteenth Kushok Bakula in Russia and Mongolia
by
Vesna A. Wallace